Journal

Tired of sweet shakes? Change the format, keep the protein

When sweet shakes wear thin, a savory mug, a clear fruit drink, a spoonable dessert, a crunchy bowl or a pack of jerky can carry the same protein.

· 5 min read

Chicken Bouillon Soup box beside a steaming mug of sipping broth

Protein shakes are the default answer when appetite is small, and for the first week they work well. Then the sweetness starts to wear. Many people find that the drink they liked on Monday is hard to face by Thursday, and a protein stop that feels like a chore is one that gets skipped. The fix is usually not a new flavor of the same shake. It is a different format: something savory, something clear, something you eat with a spoon or something you can chew.

Here are six formats in the Health Wise range, each with at least 12g of protein per serving, and how to rotate them so nothing gets old.

1. Savory and sippable: broth in a mug

Chicken Bouillon Soup is the simplest change you can make. One packet stirred into hot water gives you 16g of protein in 70 calories, with 0g of sugar. It tastes like what it is, a seasoned chicken broth, and you sip it from a mug the way you would a coffee. It also counts toward your fluids, which matters on days when you are eating and drinking less overall.

2. Savory and spoonable: a small hot bowl

When you want something that feels like dinner, the light entrées do that in a portion you can finish:

Each one is made with 5oz of water in a microwave-safe bowl and cooked in the microwave in about five to six minutes, with full stovetop directions on the product page. The entrées are $24.99 for a box of 7.

3. Clear and cold: a fruit drink instead of a milky one

A milky shake and a clear fruit drink are very different things to finish. The Wild Berry Drink is light and cold, with no milky heaviness, and you make it with cold water. If thick drinks are the problem rather than sweet ones, this is the swap to try first.

4. Spoon instead of straw: gelatin and pudding

Eating with a spoon slows you down and feels more like food than a drink does. Raspberry Gelatin sets into a dessert with 15g of protein in 80 calories and just 25mg of sodium. If you still like the chocolate flavor but are tired of drinking it, make the Chocolate Shake or Pudding with 4oz of water instead of 8oz and it sets into a thick pudding. Same 15g of protein, same 90 calories, and a completely different experience. The full method is in one packet, two ways.

5. Crunch: cereal as a snack

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cereal carries 20g of protein in 140 calories, the most protein per serving of any 7-packet box on the store. Eat it with milk at breakfast, or dry from a small bowl in the afternoon. The crunch is a welcome change after days of smooth textures. It contains peanuts and soy.

6. Chew: jerky with an egg in every pack

The Steak-N-Eggs jerky from Ovation Foods is beef steak strips with dried whole egg, 25 to 29g of protein per 1.6oz pack depending on the flavor. It is the most protein per serving we sell, and it is something to chew rather than sip. Start with the Smokehouse or the Teriyaki. Each caddy holds 10 packs for $49.99.

How to rotate so nothing gets old

A simple rule works for most people: no single format more than twice in a day. A sample rotation looks like this:

  • Morning: something warm or sweet, such as a pudding or a hot drink.
  • Midday: something savory, a mug of broth or a small bowl of chili.
  • Afternoon: something cold and clear, or something crunchy.
  • Dinner: a light entrée next to whatever small plate you can manage.

Switching format every few hours keeps each protein stop interesting, and it means the sweet products stay pleasant because you are not having them all day.

Read the label as you swap

Savory foods carry more sodium than sweet ones. Chicken Bouillon Soup has 340mg a serving, Vegetable Chili with Beans 400mg and Buttery Mashed Potatoes 400mg, against 25mg for the Raspberry Gelatin. If you are watching sodium, balance a savory meal with a lower-sodium stop later in the day, and talk to your clinician about the right level for you. Our guide to reading a nutrition label when you are eating less covers the five numbers to check.

Where to start

If you are coming off a run of sweet shakes, the Savory Six, 6 boxes is the quickest reset: two boxes of Chicken Bouillon Soup, a Vegetable Chili with Beans, a Sloppy Joe and two Buttery Mashed Potatoes, $137.94 and shipped free. For dinners only, the Dinner Month, 6 boxes is 42 light entrées for $149.94. Browse every savory option in Soups & Light Entrées.

Back to blog