Some days a drink is the easiest thing to finish. Other days you would rather sit down with a spoon. If you are eating smaller portions, on a GLP-1 program or for any other reason, being able to choose between the two from the same packet makes protein much easier to keep up. Every Health Wise Shake or Pudding packet does both jobs, and the only difference is the amount of water. This guide covers the ratios, why the format matters when your appetite is small, the mistakes that cause lumps, and five variations.
The ratios
These come straight from the directions on the carton.
- Shake: add 8oz of cold water to a 10oz or larger glass, add one packet, and stir vigorously with a spoon until smooth and creamy. A shaker bottle or blender also works.
- Pudding: add 4oz of cold water to a cup or bowl, then stir rapidly while adding one packet until it is smooth and thick. Leave it for a few minutes to set further, or chill it if you like it firmer.
The protein and calories do not change with the water. Each packet gives you 15g of protein, and the calories depend on the flavor:
- Chocolate Shake or Pudding: 15g protein, 90 calories, 0g total sugars, 2g fiber.
- Chocolate Peanut Butter Shake or Pudding: 15g protein, 100 calories, 4g fiber, made with peanut flour.
- Vanilla Shake or Pudding: 15g protein, 80 calories.
Why the format matters when appetite is small
When you can only eat a little, the best food is the one you will actually finish. A shake is quick: you can drink it in a few minutes when you are busy, and a liquid often feels lighter than a solid. A pudding takes longer to eat, feels more like a dessert, and suits people who find drinking a meal unappealing or who want to slow down and notice when they are full.
Having both options from one box also helps with the fatigue many people feel when every protein stop looks the same. The 2025 joint advisory on nutrition for GLP-1 therapy (Mozaffarian et al., American Journal of Clinical Nutrition) notes that many people taking these medicines report changes in food preferences. Changing the texture is a simple way to keep the same protein while giving yourself a different eating experience.
A worked example: one box, one week
A box holds 7 packets. Here is one way to use a box of Chocolate Shake or Pudding across a week, alternating formats so it does not get repetitive.
- Monday, Wednesday and Friday: shake at mid-morning, 8oz of cold water.
- Tuesday and Thursday: pudding in the afternoon, 4oz of cold water.
- Saturday: mocha pudding (recipe below).
- Sunday: frozen pudding made the night before.
That is 7 x 15g = 105g of protein across the week from one box, at 7 x 90 = 630 calories in total. At $18.99 a box, each serving costs $18.99 / 7 = $2.71.
Five variations
- Mocha pudding. Chocolate packet, 3oz of cold strong coffee and 1oz of cold water, stirred as a pudding. The coffee adds caffeine; the FDA cites 400 milligrams a day as an amount not generally associated with negative effects for most adults, and decaf works just as well.
- Peanut butter cup. Chocolate Peanut Butter packet as a pudding, with a few chocolate chips stirred in at the end. Our chocolate peanut butter pudding cups article has three more versions.
- Vanilla berry. Vanilla packet as a pudding, with a handful of raspberries folded in once it has set.
- Thick shake. Use 6oz of water and three ice cubes in a blender for something between a shake and a pudding.
- Frozen. Make the pudding, spoon it into a small container and freeze for two hours. Let it stand for ten minutes before eating and it eats like soft-serve.
Common mistakes
- Powder first, water second. For both formats, the carton directions put the water in first. Adding powder to water while stirring gives fewer dry pockets.
- Warm water. The carton directions call for cold water for both the shake and the pudding, so start cold for the texture the recipe was written for.
- Too little stirring. A full minute of stirring for a pudding makes a real difference. If you see lumps, keep going before you give up on it.
- Guessing the water. Use a measuring cup until you know what 4oz and 8oz look like in your favorite glass and bowl.
- Leaving it out. Once mixed, treat it like any dairy food. USDA food safety guidance is to refrigerate perishable food within 2 hours. We suggest eating a made-up pudding within a day.
Questions people ask
Can you make pudding out of protein shake mix?
With these packets, yes. They are designed for both: 8oz of cold water for a shake and 4oz for a pudding. Not every shake mix will set, so check the directions on other products.
Does making it a pudding change the protein?
No. The protein and calories come from the packet, so a pudding and a shake from the same flavor carry the same 15g of protein.
Can I make protein pudding with milk instead of water?
You can, but it adds calories and changes the texture, and the carton directions are written for water. If you try milk, start with the same amounts and expect a thicker result.
How long does protein pudding last in the fridge?
Keep it covered in the fridge and eat it within a day. Make two in the evening and tomorrow's afternoon protein is ready.
All three flavors are in the Shakes & Puddings collection, and the Shake Month bundle puts six boxes together.