When your appetite is small, dessert is often the one thing that still sounds good, and it is also the meal most likely to carry almost no protein. If you are on a GLP-1 program or simply eating less, a pudding that tastes like a peanut butter cup but carries a full protein stop is a useful thing to have in the fridge. This article gives three ways to make one from a single packet, explains what makes it work for small appetites, and covers how to make it ahead and store it safely.
What is in the packet
The Chocolate Peanut Butter Shake or Pudding packet is made with peanut flour and cocoa. According to its Nutrition Facts panel, one 30g packet gives you 15g of protein, 100 calories, 7g of carbohydrate, 4g of fiber, 2g of total sugars and 0g of added sugars. Made with 8oz of cold water it is a shake; with 4oz it sets into a pudding thick enough to hold a spoon.
It contains milk, peanuts and soy. If anyone who will eat it has a peanut allergy, this is not the right pudding.
Why a pudding works on a small appetite
A pudding is eaten slowly, with a spoon, which many people find easier than drinking a full glass when they are already close to full. It also feels like a treat, which matters when food has become a task. The 2025 joint advisory on nutrition for GLP-1 therapy (Mozaffarian et al., American Journal of Clinical Nutrition) notes that many people on these medicines report changes in what foods appeal to them. Having a familiar dessert flavor that also does a protein job gives you an option on days when savory food does not.
The 4g of fiber is worth noting too. Fiber intake often falls when total food falls, and the same advisory encourages adequate fiber from foods.
Classic pudding cup
Serves one. 15g protein, 100 calories.
- Put 4oz of cold water in a small bowl.
- Add one packet while stirring rapidly, and keep stirring for a full minute until there are no dry pockets.
- Leave it for five minutes to set. Chill it for ten if you want it firmer.
Frozen peanut butter cup
Serves one. 15g protein, 100 calories.
- Make the classic pudding.
- Spoon it into a small ramekin or silicone muffin cup.
- Freeze for two hours. Take it out ten minutes before eating.
It eats like a dense soft-serve. If you have the room, three or four dark chocolate chips pressed into the top before freezing make it feel like a proper dessert; count their calories from the chip bag.
Banana layer
Serves one. About 15g protein and about 135 calories.
- Slice a third of a medium banana thinly.
- Make the classic pudding.
- In a small glass, layer half the pudding, then the banana, then the rest of the pudding.
- Chill for ten minutes.
The working: USDA FoodData Central lists a medium banana at about 105 calories, so a third is about 35 calories, added to the pudding's 100. The banana adds well under 1g of protein, so the total stays at about 15g. Some people find the fruit makes a small portion easier to finish.
A worked example: one box across a week
A box holds 7 packets at $18.99, which is $18.99 / 7 = $2.71 a serving. One way to use it:
- Four afternoons: classic pudding cup, made the evening before.
- Two evenings: frozen peanut butter cup.
- One weekend: banana layer.
That is 7 x 15g = 105g of protein across the week, and 28g of fiber from the packets alone (7 x 4g).
Making it ahead and storing it
Pudding is easiest when it is already made. Mix two in the evening, cover them and put them in the fridge, and the next day's afternoon stops are done. Treat a made-up pudding like any dairy food. USDA food safety guidance is to refrigerate perishable food within 2 hours and keep the fridge at 40°F or below. We suggest eating a made-up pudding within a day. The frozen version keeps longer in the freezer, but the texture is best within a few days.
Common mistakes
- Dumping the packet in all at once. Add it to the water while stirring, or you get dry pockets at the bottom.
- Stopping too soon. A full minute of stirring is what turns it from a thick drink into a pudding.
- Using warm water. The carton directions call for cold water.
- Loading it with toppings. A spoonful of peanut butter on top adds about 95 calories for a tablespoon. If you want more peanut flavor, a teaspoon goes a long way.
- Eating it straight from the freezer. Give the frozen version ten minutes, or it is too hard to spoon.
Questions people ask
How do you make protein pudding from a shake mix?
Use half the water. For this packet, 4oz of cold water makes a pudding and 8oz makes a shake. Our guide to the shake-or-pudding method covers all three flavors.
Can you freeze protein pudding?
Yes. Spoon it into a small container, freeze for two hours and let it stand for ten minutes before eating.
Is chocolate peanut butter protein pudding high in sugar?
This one has 2g of total sugars and 0g of added sugars per serving, according to its Nutrition Facts panel.
How long does homemade protein pudding last in the fridge?
Keep it covered and chilled, and eat it within a day for the best texture.
For more spoon-friendly options, browse the Shakes & Puddings collection.